Revenue Cycle Tips

How One Practice Cut Claim Denials by 40% (Sample Case Study)

Medical practice owner and billing manager celebrating improved performance with a handshake during a business meeting.

Every denied claim costs a practice twice: once in delayed revenue, and again in the staff time it takes to research, fix and resubmit it. When denials climb, the billing team spends its days on rework instead of getting new claims out clean.

This case study walks through how a practice can cut its denials by 40% in six months, step by step, and what real organizations have reported when they made the same kinds of changes.

About this case study

This is a sample case study. To protect client privacy, 4Arcs does not publish real client data. The practice, numbers and timeline below are a composite example built from common denial patterns and the steps that published case studies, cited further down, describe. Real results vary by practice, specialty and payer mix.

Short answer

Most practices that cut denials sharply do not find one magic fix. They sort every denial by root cause, fix the front end first (eligibility, registration and prior authorization), tighten coding and claim checks, and give each denial category a clear owner who reviews it on a fixed schedule. In our sample practice, that approach took the denial rate from 12% to 7.2% in six months, a 40% reduction. Published case studies from real health systems report similar or larger drops in the denial types they targeted.

Who this article is for

Practice owners, practice managers and billing leads who are tired of reworking the same denials and want a realistic plan, with real-world examples, for bringing them down.

Key takeaways

Why denials deserve your attention now

Denials are not a small-practice problem or a big-system problem. They are an everyone problem, and for many groups they have been getting worse.

60%

of medical group leaders reported rising claim denial rates in an MGMA Stat poll (March 5, 2024; 235 responses). Only 11% saw a decrease.

Source: MGMA Stat

8%

of claims denied on first submission, a single-specialty aggregate from the 2023 MGMA DataDive Practice Operations data set, as reported by MGMA.

Source: MGMA

The sample practice: where the denials came from

Sample practice profile

The first step was a denial audit: every denial from the previous three months, grouped by root cause rather than by payer code alone. The before column below shows what the audit found. The after column is month six, covered later in this article.

Denial category (sample data)

Before

After

Change

Eligibility and registration

70

30

-57%

Prior authorization

40

25

-38%

Coding

35

25

-29%

Missing information or documentation

20

13

-35%

Timely filing

5

2

-60%

Other

10

13

+30%

Total denials per month

180

108

-40%

Sample data for illustration only. Monthly denials based on about 1,500 claims a month.

What the practice changed, month by month

Each step below is part of the sample case. Under each one is a real-world parallel from a published source, so you can see the same idea working outside our example.

Month 1

Denial audit and ownership

Grouped three months of denials by root cause, set a baseline, and assigned each category to an owner: front desk for eligibility and registration, a billing lead for authorizations, a coder for coding denials.

Real-world parallel: UC Davis Health built a denial taxonomy linking payer codes to the teams that own them. (Becker’s)

Months 1 to 2

Front-end eligibility fixes

Moved insurance checks to two business days before each visit using electronic eligibility transactions, added coordination of benefits questions at scheduling, and trained the front desk on plan types.

Real-world parallel: Wooster Community Hospital paired real-time 270/271 eligibility checks with monthly staff training. (HFMA)

Months 2 to 3

Prior authorization tracking

Built a simple authorization log for services that need approval, with a check before scheduling and a hold rule if approval is missing.

Real-world parallel: NCH Medical Group holds the front end accountable for denials it can prevent. (Becker’s)

Months 3 to 4

Coding review and claim scrubbing

Reviewed the top coding denials with providers, updated templates, and turned on payer-specific claim edits before submission.

Real-world parallel: UC Davis Health shifted effort from low-value appeals to prevention, including documentation improvement. (Becker’s)

Ongoing

Weekly queues and monthly reviews

Worked denials in weekly queues by category, tracked appeal deadlines, and held a monthly review with each specialty lead.

Real-world parallel: NCH Medical Group meets monthly with each specialty leader to review denials by category. (Becker’s)

The results after six months

Measure (sample data)

Before

Month 6

Change

Denial rate

12%

7.2%

-40%

Denials per month

180

108

-40%

Eligibility and registration denials

70

30

-57%

The biggest drop came from eligibility and registration, the category the practice fixed first. Coding and prior authorization denials fell more slowly, because they depend on provider documentation and payer rules that take longer to change. In the sample, the “other” category rose slightly as the team started classifying denials more carefully.

Sample data for illustration only. Not a real 4Arcs client result.

What real organizations have reported

These are published results from named organizations. They are hospitals and health systems, not small practices, and they measured specific denial types rather than overall denial rates. Vendor case studies are written by the company that sold the solution, so read them with that in mind.

Independent case study

Wooster Community Hospital (Ohio)

Reported result: Registration denials fell by more than 50%, or $11.5 million, after a year. Registration denials had been about 40% of the hospital’s denied dollars.

What they changed: Real-time 270/271 eligibility checks, a monthly revenue cycle boot camp for patient access staff, an updated insurance dictionary, and a shared email for quick plan questions.

Vendor case study

MetroHealth

Reported result: 44.1% fewer coordination of benefits denials, 37.3% fewer eligibility denials and 20.3% fewer registration denials, as reported by the vendor.

What they changed: Replaced manual registration checks with one automated check for eligibility, coordination of benefits and demographics, returned into the EHR.

Vendor case study

Columbus Regional Health

Reported result: 41% fewer eligibility denials and 37% fewer coordination of benefits and registration denials, as reported by the vendor.

What they changed: Automated eligibility and coverage checks that flag only the cases needing staff review.

Rules that shape denial work

Denial reduction happens inside deadlines and standards set by Medicare, HIPAA and payers. Sources were checked on October 22, 2026.

Medicare program rule

Timely filing

Issued by: CMS · Reference: 42 CFR 424.44

Medicare fee-for-service claims must be filed within one calendar year of the date of service. Commercial payers set their own limits in contracts.

What to do: Track filing deadlines by payer and correct denied claims before the window closes.

Official source: eCFR: 42 CFR 424.44

Medicare program rule

Appeal deadline (redetermination)

Issued by: CMS · Reference: 42 CFR 405.942

A Medicare redetermination request must be filed within 120 calendar days of receiving the initial determination, with receipt presumed 5 days after the notice date.

What to do: Add appeal deadlines to your denial work queues so appealable claims are not lost.

Official source: eCFR: 42 CFR 405.942

Federal law

Electronic eligibility transactions

Issued by: HHS / CMS · Reference: 45 CFR Part 162

Eligibility checks sent electronically must use the HIPAA standard 270/271 transaction, which is what makes automated pre-visit checks possible across payers.

What to do: Use your clearinghouse or practice management system for electronic eligibility checks.

Official source: CMS: Adopted Standards

Federal rule for certain payers

Specific reasons for prior authorization denials

Issued by: CMS · Reference: CMS-0057-F

Beginning in 2026, Medicare Advantage, Medicaid and CHIP programs and plans, and QHP issuers on the Federally Facilitated Exchanges must give a specific reason when they deny a prior authorization (drugs excluded).

What to do: Log the stated reason for each authorization denial so patterns become visible.

Official source: CMS fact sheet: CMS-0057-F

Legal requirement or best practice? The Medicare deadlines and HIPAA standards are requirements. The CMS-0057-F rule binds the listed payers, not your practice. The steps in this case study are recommended practices. Commercial payers set their own deadlines and appeal rules in their contracts. This article is general education, not legal advice.

How to run the same playbook in your practice

These are recommended steps, not legal requirements. Start small and keep measuring.

01

Pull three months of denials

Export every denial with its reason code, payer, service and amount.

02

Group them by root cause

Use categories your team understands: eligibility, authorization, coding, documentation, timely filing, other.

03

Give each category an owner

The person or team that can prevent the denial owns it, not just the person who reworks it.

04

Fix the front end first

Eligibility and registration fixes are usually fastest. See how eligibility verification prevents denials.

05

Work denials weekly, review monthly

Weekly queues keep appeals on time; monthly reviews show whether root causes are fixed. Our 10-step denial guide goes deeper.

06

Measure the same way every month

Track denial rate, denials by category, and dollars recovered, so you can see real progress.

Frequently asked questions

Is a 40% reduction in claim denials realistic?

It depends on where you start. Practices with many preventable front-end denials have the most room to improve. Published case studies from health systems report reductions of 37% to more than 50% in the specific denial types they targeted.

No. To protect client privacy, the practice and numbers in this article are sample data. The real-world results come from published case studies, each linked to its source.

Usually eligibility and registration denials, because they are common and preventable with checks before the visit. Your own denial audit should confirm where to start.

Front-end fixes can show results within one or two billing cycles. Coding and authorization improvements usually take longer because they involve provider documentation and payer rules.

A Medicare redetermination must be requested within 120 days of receiving the initial determination. Commercial payers set their own deadlines.

The bottom line

Cutting denials by 40% is less about working harder on rework and more about stopping denials before they happen. Measure them by root cause, fix the front end first, give every category an owner, and review progress every month. That is the same approach behind the real-world results above, and the approach our denial management and eligibility verification teams use at 4Arcs. If you would rather hand off the whole process, our revenue cycle management service covers it end to end.

What to do next

Find out where your own denials come from before deciding what to fix first.

No obligation. No patient information needed.

Share this article

Keep Reading

Related
Articles

More practical guides from our billing team on the same topic.

Free Billing Analysis

Want These Insights Applied to Your Practice?

Book a free 30-minute call. We review your denials, A/R and workflow and show you what to fix first.